Top 7 Email Marketing Trends for Online Business Owners to Watch in 2026
- Kathy Farah
- Dec 11, 2025
- 4 min read
Updated: Dec 17, 2025
Most trend reports recycle the same ideas. More personalization. More automation. More AI. None of this helps you decide what to send next Tuesday.
This report is grounded in what I see every week inside real Kit (formerly ConvertKit) accounts. I work with online service providers, coaches, consultants, and businesses that rely on email for revenue, where subscribers pay attention, where they drop off, and where systems break.
Across every client, one theme keeps showing up:
There is no universal best practice. Only what your audience proves through data.
These aren’t predictions. These are patterns already happening in the inbox.
1. More email isn’t better. The right cadence is.
Earlier this year, I tested the advice many experts give: email more often. I went from weekly emails to three times a week.
Here’s what my audience told me through data:
• Open rates dropped from 50 to 60 percent to 38 to 40 percent
• Engagement felt thinner
• Click patterns became less intentional
Nothing was wrong with the content or deliverability.
The audience simply didn’t want that much email.
When I returned to weekly emails, the open rate jumped to 52 percent.
The takeaway isn’t “weekly is best for everyone.”
The takeaway is:
Your audience will tell you the right cadence. Test and listen.
Most online business owners default to sending more because they think frequency equals visibility.
In reality, frequency without strategy creates fatigue and trains subscribers to skim.
Weekly email works for my audience because it balances consistency with breathing room.
Your audience may prefer something different.
The only best practice is the one your data confirms.
2. Your welcome sequence will matter more than your newsletter
Most welcome sequences were written years ago. Offers changed. Messaging evolved. The audience shifted. The emails stayed the same.
A strong welcome sequence increases engagement and conversions. A stale one accelerates unsubscribes.
The fix is simple:
Use a 3–4 email welcome sequence that leads to one clear next step.
Here’s where Ed Gandia’s NYR (not-yet-ready) principle becomes powerful.
He teaches that one direct question can reopen a conversation.
Use that in the final welcome email:
• “Are you still thinking about improving your email system?”
• “Is building a more consistent email rhythm a priority for you right now?”
• “Would support mapping your next 30 days be helpful?”
Short. Direct. Human.
Your welcome sequence is your first impression. Your first impression influences deliverability. Deliverability influences everything else.
3. AI will accelerate production, but humans must set the strategy
AI now drafts newsletters, sales emails, nurture sequences, and entire funnels.
The problem isn’t the tool.
The problem is when AI becomes the strategist.
Most AI-written emails sound the same: over-polished, over-apologetic, and full of phrases no human would say.
AI predicts words. It does not:
• understand timing
• recognize readiness
• understand your offer path
• assess buyer psychology
Use AI for structure and speed.
You set the message, angle, and logic.
If AI is leading your content, you don’t have a strategy. You have word prediction.
Which of these email marketing shifts do you think will have the biggest impact on your revenue in 2026?
Finding the right sending cadence (not just “more email”)
Revamping my welcome sequence to feel fresh and human
Mastering quick, personalized follow-ups (like the 48-hour r
Shifting to behavior-based signals over basic segmentation
4. Follow-up will be the most undervalued revenue driver
Most email systems break in the same place.
Someone clicks. Silence. Someone replies. Silence. Someone joins your list. One email, then silence.
Use the 48-hour follow-up strategy, inspired by my client work.
When someone takes action, follow up within 48 hours:
• If they click a sales link → follow up
• If they join your list → send the full welcome sequence
• If they reply → respond quickly
For an easy script, use Phil M. Jones’ question from Exactly What to Say:
“What questions do you have for me?”
This one question consistently opens conversations and moves work forward.
5. Lead magnets must create movement, not information overload
People don’t want more information. They want help taking the next step.
Lead magnets that reflect what your audience is already clicking, asking, or struggling with will consistently outperform generic ‘best practice’ freebies.
Information-based lead magnet:
“10 Email Subject Lines You Can Try”
Movement-based lead magnet: “Write Your Next Subject Line in 3 Minutes Using This Guided Formula”
One creates overwhelm.
One creates momentum.
Ask: Does this help someone take one meaningful step in under five minutes? If not, refine it.
6. Behavior signals will outperform demographic segmentation
Segmentation used to be about industry, niche, or interest.
In 2026, behavior is the better predictor of readiness.
Behavior signals you can trust:
• what they clicked
• how many times they clicked
• which topics attracted attention
• whether they replied
Most business owners ignore this. Operators don’t.
Start simple:
Review who clicked your last email and send each person one short message.
Try:
• “I saw you clicked on this. Are you still thinking about improving it?”
• “What questions do you have about this?”
Manual before automated.
Conversation before building the funnel.
When the same topic gets repeated clicks across multiple emails, that’s your signal to automate a follow-up path.
Email 1: A direct question tied to the topic they clicked
Email 2: A clear next step if they want support
Creators publish and hope.
Operators notice and follow up.
7. Operators will outperform creators
This is the trend behind every other trend.
Creators focus on content. Operators focus on systems.
Creators push volume.
Operators build pathways.
Creators publish.
Operators interpret behavior and adjust.
Operators win because they:
• test cadence
• follow up consistently
• update their welcome sequence
• track behavior, not vanity metrics
• use AI intentionally
• clean their lists
• build systems that support their offers
This is the shift that will define email marketing in 2026.
Want to build your 2026 email plan?
If you want a system that aligns with how you work, how your audience behaves, and how your offers convert, let’s map it together.
Comments